Towards an Infrastructure for Knowledge Management within European Ethics: Methodologies for Semantic Integration of Heterogeneous Resources

Report for the Feasibility Study for an Advanced Systematic Documentation, Information and Communication Tool in the Field of Ethical Issues in Science, Research and Technology (FASTER)

Work Package 5B: Communication Links


Food and Agricultural Organization
Library and Documentation Systems Division
WAICENT/FAOINFO Dissemination Management Branch
 
Table of Contents


Participants Work Package 5 B - Contact Information

Food and Agricultural Organization
Library and Documentation Systems Division
WAICENT/FAOINFO Dissemination Management Branch
viale delle Terme di Caracalla
Rome 00100
ITALY

Johannes Keizer
[email protected]

Anita Liang
[email protected]

Contributors

Gauri Salokhe
Margherita Sini

Abstract

As with many domains, information retrieval and knowledge management (IR/KM) in ethics suffers from the problems of semantic heterogeneity, making it difficult for providers to disseminate their services effectively and for users to retrieve the information they need. An analysis was conducted of resources provided by two hundred or so information services within the domain of ethics as it applies to issues in science, technology, and research in a European context. Based on this analysis, this paper proposes a) an application profile for dealing with the problem of heterogeneity originating from differences in terminologies, domain coverage, and domain modelling, and b) a root ontology based on the application profile which can serve as a basis for extending knowledge of the domain.


Contents

INTRODUCTION

SEMANTIC WEB

The XML layer: Content of a resource

Granularity

The RDF layer: Metadata of a resource
The Ontology layer: Modelling the domain

METHODOLOGIES FOR SEMANTIC INTEGRATION

Ethics Application Profile

Definition and rationale
Methodology for the development of a European Ethics application profile (EEAP)

Ethics Application Ontology

Definition and rationale
Mapping the application profile to the application ontology
The ongoing development of the EEAO
Methodology for ontology-building

SCENARIOS: RELATING ONTOLOGIES AND DATA

Mediated (centralized) v. federated multi-host (distributed) architecture
Three scenarios

The AO and unindexed structured data
The SO and unstructured data
The AO + one or more thesauri
The AO + sub-ontology

CONCLUSION

REFERENCES