Thumbnail Image

Turning threats into opportunities: An analysis of the response of palm oil companies implementing NDPE commitment to NGO complaints

XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022

Year of publication 2022

Place of publication Rome, Italy ;

Pages 6p.

Author Dermawan, A., Hospes, O., Purnomo, H.

Publisher FAO ;

Product type Article

Synopsis (short abstract) Since the early 2010s, several palm oil companies committed to produce and trade palm oil that is termed “no deforestation, no peatland, and no exploitation” (NDPE). Nongovernmental organizations (NGO) are generally supportive of the commitment. However, they remain critical of how the companies implement their commitment. The paper aims to answer the question of “how to do the palm oil companies implementing the NDPE commitment navigate around the complaints of the NGOs?” We applied and adopted the corporate political activity (CPA) concept. Specifically, we used and extended corporate strategies to manage Kneip (2013) protests and Balsiger (2014). We analyzed over 150 complaints of the NGOs to six major palm oil companies from 2014 to 2019. We found that 1) the complaints are related to one or a combination of breaches in deforestation, peatland, and exploitation; 2) the protests are not only addressed to the companies or their subsidiaries but also the third-party suppliers; 3) it generally takes longer to resolve cases related to exploitation than deforestation and peatland. We argue that the companies navigate around the complaints by applying one or a combination of the responses to the NGO complaints. Using the CPA framework, we say that the companies largely apply information and vertical constituent-building strategies to strengthen their supply base to comply with the companies’ NDPE commitment. The implication is that any commitment towards reducing or ending deforestation should consider the importance of respecting communities’ rights. Keywords: Deforestation and forest degradation, Value chain, Partnerships, Policies, Policies ID: 3486658

Language English

Also available in:
No results found.

Related items

Showing items related by metadata.

  • Thumbnail Image
    Document
    A social and gender analysis of FLEGT: Analyzing opportunities and risks for wood processing and furniture small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Lao PDR
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    Illegal logging and deforestation has become a pervasive issue globally contributing to environmental degradation and climate change in recent decades. Various policy measures have been enacted to mitigate unethical and extractive practices that have jeopardized forest ecosystems and the communities dependent on them, such as the Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade (FLEGT) program. Increasingly, there has been a growing body of research on the implications of FLEGT-related policies on the timber supply chain in VPA negotiating countries. While FLEGT is touted to improve forest governance and provide economic benefits, the commercialization and market formalization of FLEGT processes render dangerous possibilities for small and medium enterprises (SMEs). While recent efforts have assessed how FLEGT can ameliorate timber product output and reduce illegal forest activity, most of this analysis is disaggregated by the size and scale of timber producing operations, and has not considered the social and gendered implications of these policies on various actors along the timber production supply chain. Through a case study of Xayaboury, Lao PDR, our research examined how the VPA process will impact SMEs, and consequently the diverse demographic populations within them. Through focus group discussions and semi-structured interviews with government officials, private sector, civil societies, and SME labourers and owners from the local to the national level, we examined how FLEGT policies has social and gender ramifications in Lao wood processing and furniture SMEs. This research found that small-scale sawmills, women labourers, and local-level women's groups and civil societies are particulalry met with vulnerability due to FLEGT, with few to none safeguarding policies protecting their rights. We argue that policy revisions within the FLEGT and Forestry policies should be amended to protect marginalized communities' rights amidst timber legality and policy changes. Keywords: Gender, Deforestation and forest degradation, Social protection, Sustainable forest management, Illegal trade ID: 3623113
  • Thumbnail Image
    Article
    From waste to value: Development of parallel strand lumber from oil palm trunk waste as an alternative to wood
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    The innovation of parallel strand lumber (PSL) from oil palm trunk waste was intended to develop alternative raw materials other than wood as well as improve the characteristics of the oil palm trunk. This study aims to analyze the effect of soaking duration on the phenol-formaldehyde adhesive solution to the characteristics of PSL. Variations of soaking duration used in this study were 30, 60, 90, and 120 minutes. The results of this study showed the modulus of elasticity (MOE) ranged from 53.7 × 103 to 103.2 × 103 kg/cm3 while the modulus of rupture (MOR) ranged from 358 to 596 kg/cm2 . The compressive strength ranged from 301.86 to 439.96 kg/cm2. The hardness of horizontal, vertical, and parallel grain ranged from 439.17 to 747.41 kg/cm2 , 361.86 to 526.01 kg/cm2, and 285.09 to 451.09 kg/cm2, respectively. The best quality of PSL which was soaked in a phenol- formaldehyde adhesive solution for 120 minutes. It can be concluded that oil palm trunk waste can be utilized to substitute the wood for lightweight construction material and support the development of green material. Keywords: green material, oil palm trunk, parallel strand lumber, phenol-formaldehyde, waste ID: 3488514
  • Thumbnail Image
    Article
    Being legal and formal? Opportunities and challenges of the timber legality verification system for smallscale furniture producers in Indonesia
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    Over the last decade, Indonesia has made significant strides in improving forest governance. The Government of Indonesia (GoI) has made curbing illegal logging a strategic goal within the Ministry of Forestry's long-term plan. One of the main milestones in improving forest governance in Indonesia is signing the Voluntary Partnership Agreement (VPA) with the European Union and being the first country that obtains the FLEGT license. The GoI has developed a timber legality assurance system called Timber Legality Verification System (Sistem Verifikasi Legalitas Kayu - SVLK). This system enables tracking a piece of timber back until the origin and ensure its legality. One major issue that remains under contention is how small actors should be included in the SVLK system. This paper attempts to assess the financial implications of SVLK certification for small operators in Indonesia. We found that while there are opportunities for smallscale producers to access the international market by having SVLK certificate, they face challenges to become formal entities. Moreover, they are hampered by the scale needed to enable them to meet the demand from global buyers. The paper aims to generate lessons for Indonesia to deal with small operators' inclusion into the FLEGT process and other countries seeking similar VPA arrangements with the EU to draw lessons from Indonesia as the first country that has obtained FLEGT license. Keywords: Value chain, Illegal trade, Policies, Policies, Research ID: 3486706
Show more

Users also downloaded

Showing related downloaded files

No results found.