Thumbnail Image

Community resilience to changes in forest public policies: The case of ejidos in northern Mexico

XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022

Year of publication 2022

Place of publication Rome, Italy ;

Pages 9p.

Author Perez‐Verdin, G., Heredia‐Telles, A.

Publisher FAO ;

Product type Article

Synopsis (short abstract) The communal property regime in Mexico, in which land use and management rights were officially granted to campesinos, has faced many challenges throughout the nearly 100 years after its creation. Since then, a variety of public policies have been established to promote forest management. In the 1970s, the government created a forest management system based on concessions to private or parastatal companies that ignored the opinions of the communities and triggered environmental problems. Later, it initiated other programs, such as the payment for ecosystem services, to reduce deforestation and poverty. However, no empirical evidence of these policies has been studied. In this work, we analyzed the historical role in forest management of three ejidos in the state of Durango, including their organization, capacity building, and their relationship with forest cover changes. Two periods, ranging from the beginning of the concessions to current community forest management (1960‐2018), were compared. Based on Ostrom’s principles of collective action, the effectiveness of the ejidos in conserving their resources was analyzed. Semi‐structured interviews were used to estimate two indexes that associate the internal organization of the communities: Social Organization and Community Institutionality. The cartographic series of the National Institute of Statistics and Geography were also used to evaluate the changes in forest cover in the same period. Results show that the indexes have increased over time, suggesting that ejidos have improved their organization processes. In addition, there is a direct relationship between the forest land increase and both indices. The so‐called community forest management model is a feasible strategy that can contribute to the preservation of these ecosystems. The internal organization of the communities, including their institutional arrangements, is a key factor to search for the sustainable management of these common‐pool resources. Keywords: Collective Action, Common‐Pool Resources, Community Forest Management, Forestland ID: 3613102 Use Change, Social Organization

Language English

Also available in:
No results found.

Related items

Showing items related by metadata.

  • Thumbnail Image
    Article
    Conditions for successful local collective action in mangrove forest management: Some evidence from the Eastern coastal area of south Sulawesi, Indonesia
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    Resource management characterized by Common Pool Resources (CPRs) requires collective action for its sustainable management. CPRs with “rivalry” and “non-excludable” features face overexploitation problems because unlike the nature of pure public goods, the use of CPRs by one user will reduce the chances of other users taking advantage of it. This study aims to analyze the most appropriate local institutions and tenure arrangements for sustainable mangrove management in Eastern coast area of South Sulawesi, Indonesia. Data and information were collected through in-depth interviews involving key informants selected by using snow- ball method and continued by Focus Group Discussion. Design principles for sustainable management of common pool resources from Ostrom has been used in this study as an analytical framework which illustrate the structure of rules established and imposed by the local CPR’s institutions. The findings show that collective action in sustainable mangrove management can be achieved through accepted rules and agreements that are participatory formulated. The agreed norms and rules have enacted as a benchmark for collective action in maintaining mangrove and to enforce sanctions for violators. The success of the community in sustainable mangrove resources management is mainly supported by the existence of several prerequisites that facilitate collective action. It is necessary to strengthen regulations both at the local and higher level through socialization to the community along with the development of incentive and disincentives system. Keywords: Community, local institution, mangrove function, participatory rule setting ID: 3486273
  • Thumbnail Image
    Article
    Van panchayats of Uttarakhand as role model for community forest management
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    Community forests, in a sharp contrast to government forest or private forest, are by and large severely degraded and subject to deforestation easily. They manifest ‘tragedy of the commons’ (Hardin, 1968). Contradicting this conventional wisdom is the institution of Van Panchayats, in the Himalayan state of Uttarakhand in India. Their history is that of conflict (against rigid government control) to collaboration (on community management and control). Van Panchayats are village level, democratically elected, grass root level natural resource management bodies. They have successfully cleared all the three aspects of sustainability, that is: social acceptability, technical feasibility, and economic viability. Starting with few in 1930's, their number has swelled to 12,089 and cover more than 7,350.85 square kilometre area which is approximately 13.41% of the total forest area of Uttarakhand. They are easily one of the best examples of participation of all stakeholders including women, weaker and marginalized sections of the society, in the management, decision making, and sharing of usufructs. In externally aided projects by the World Bank, Japan International Cooperation Agency (JAICA), their role has been appreciated and they have been assigned various key works of connservation/development. Various nongovernmental organizations have also lauded the contribution of Van Panchayats at various forums. More management inputs and facilitation by government orders to ensure implementation of all village level schemes through them is required to make them still more vibrant and self-sustaining. Van Panchayats are the practical manifestation of the thoughts echoed by Nobel Laureate Elinor Ostrom (2002) demonstrating how local communities can use natural resources in a judicious and commonly acceptable manner. With suitable modifications they can be used worldwide for management of community lands for sustainable environmental, ecological, and economic benefits. Keywords: Social protection, Conflict, Deforestation and forest degradation, Sustainable forest management, Gender ID: 3484260
  • Thumbnail Image
    Article
    Land tenure governance approaches that tackle policy incoherence, secure rights, improve livelihoods, and maintain forests: Replicable and scalable lessons from a grassroot experience in Honduras
    XV World Forestry Congress, 2-6 May 2022
    2022
    Also available in:
    No results found.
    Insecure forest tenure can hamper even the most exemplary community forestry management initiatives. This paper describes and reflects on the case study of the Villa Santa Agroforestry Cooperative, a community organization located in eastern Honduras. Due to policy incoherence, the public forest area concessioned to them since the 1970's was later subjected to land privatization-individual titling schemes based on Agrarian Reform policies. This disrupted and fragmented the former collective tenure regime under which the Cooperative had well managed the forest. In 2012, the concession was almost revoked due to this situation threatening the livelihoods of hundreds of families that depended on it. Despite the challenging context, the institutional leadership and commitment shown by a renewed forest administration and the Cooperative reverted this decision. In 2013, both entities initiated an ample Forest-Land Regularization Process that included the cadaster of all public and private plots and their right holders. Wide open consultations were held with stakeholders, including private land-owners who negotiated mechanisms to work with the Cooperative. As a result, a Public-Private Forest Management Plan was approved; an innovative scheme that remains to this day the only of its kind in Honduras. These processes enabled the Cooperative to attract investments from government, private sector and donors, including agroforestry schemes to restore degraded areas and diversify incomes. Also, transactional costs of traditional activities like pine resination have lowered, and thus continue to sustain communities' livelihoods in the midst of the COVID19 crisis. Further research is still needed to evaluate the scale of the impact and sustainability of the initiatives, but the initial outcomes show the need to escalate its lessons and good practices to a renewed nation-wide community forestry policy that can better contribute to the SDG's livelihood and conservation objectives. Keywords: Forest tenure; Secure land rights; Collective land rights; Community-based forestry; Honduras ID: 3485859
Show more

Users also downloaded

Showing related downloaded files

No results found.